Resume Black Hole

Many job seekers feel applying online on a company’s career site is like throwing their resume into a black hole; it will never be seen again.  Why do companies require this step?

I have found three main reasons why employers force applicants to apply online.

1) Organization and Efficiency: With the advent of the internet and online applications, the number of resumes sent to a hiring organization has skyrocketed.  Receiving hundreds of applications for a single job posting is not unusual, employers need some way to organize the deluge of applications.  Compounding the issue is the cutting of HR/recruiting staffs in an effort to control costs and increase profits.  Online application databases such as Taleo, Brassring, or other similar technologies allow fewer recruiters to sift through more applications than their counterparts 15 years ago.

In addition, having applicants in a central database allows organizations to easily create correspondence (offer letters, rejection letters, etc.) and move individual records in

2) Filtering: A few years ago,  a manager I know needed to backfill an administrative assistant position within his office because the current employee in the role had been promoted.  As with most hiring managers, recruiting and hiring this person was an additional task that was assigned to him – it was not part of his daily or primary duties.  When hundreds of applications came in for the position, he needed some way to filter through the applications.

Enter the applicant tracking system, or ATS (ex: Taleo and Brassring).  ATS allow the hiring manager to enter in criteria to filter applications.  Gone are applicants more than 30 miles from the work site (done through zip code filter), eliminate any applicant who do not have a Bachelors degree (filter the Education entries), keep applicants who have certain key words, typically technical skills, in their applications (Excel, Salesforce, Access, SEO, Bloomberg Terminal, etc.).  ATS can take a pile of 1000 applications and allow the user to filter to a more manageable number, and higher overall quality, of applications to review.

3) OFCCP Compliance: The Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs is housed within the Department of Labor and its stated mission is:

The purpose of the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs is to enforce, for the benefit of job seekers and wage earners, the contractual promise of affirmative action and equal employment opportunity required of those who do business with the Federal government.

What does this mean to an applicant?  Any company that does business with the Federal government is subject to OFCCP audits if questions arise about the company’s hiring practices.  Let’s take Boeing for example: say they have a contract with the Federal government to build a new fighter for the Air Force.  Officials from OFCCP can audit Boeing and inquire how John Q. Engineer was hired into Boeing.  Boeing must be able to track what job John Q. Engineer was hired into, who applied for that same job, the filtering criteria used to eliminate 90% of the applicants, etc.  Basically, the federal government could inquire how any Boeing employee came into the company and the company would need to prove there was no favoritism/nepotism/illegal hire-isms that led to the hiring of the individual.

The only way Boeing could possibly keep track of who applied for what job, what filtering criteria was used to narrow the field, etc. is to keep records on a central database.  Again, enter the Applicant Tracking System as it houses all applicants, the filters used to arrive at the final group who received phone screens or interviews.  The risks of losing a government contract are so high that employers need everyone to go through a central portal in order to ensure no one record was overlooked.

As an applicant, you may not like to hear that your resume may not be read, that is just filtered out because your application did not have the right keywords or you live 5 miles too far from the work site.  The fact is that this happens, and probably more often than one would think.  Still, knowing what you are up against, one can now strategize on how to counter the ATS.

Tomorrow – strategies for not allowing yourself to be at the mercy of  the ATS.


About Kevin Monahan

I have 10+ years experience in coaching clients in their career management and career change efforts. Personal career consulting services combined with employer outreach to help find opportunities for both constituents.
This entry was posted in Application, Career Management, Job Boards, Job Search, online and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Resume Black Hole

  1. Pingback: Beating “Apply Online” | Career Seeker's Guide

  2. Saw this on a posting from Feb. 13th:

    “The average number of applications submitted per job opening fell to 118 in the fourth quarter, from 187 during the same period in 2010, according to new research from the Corporate Executive Board.

    However, among those applicants, just 35% met the basic experience, education and skills requirements listed for the position. Previously, that figure stood at 32%.

    The study, which polled more than 215 recruiters, mostly at large companies, found that “serial applicants”—job seekers who apply online to several positions in a single blast—are one reason why the job-screening process continues to be so time consuming. Recruiters take 9.5 hours, on average, to screen résumés and applications submitted for a single job opening, the study found.”

    35% of applicants were qualified, no wonder why companies use filtering systems.

  3. Lacey says:

    My main job search area is Chicago where I have a PO Box address but I’m applying to jobs in the south and could pack up and move in days. How do I avoid the zip code filter for those positions and convey I could start faster than a local candidate and would pay my own moving expenses?

  4. joni says:

    Yes you can weed through them faster, but….you turn the entire process into a mind numbing less than human approach to hiring. That hundreds would apply for one position says something about our economy, but that is another story. You simply cannot let a computer program as pitiful as taleo and brass ring, which frustrates users to the point of insanity, pick your applicants. You will not get the best taking this shortcut. I wont fill another one of them. Nor will I think of ways to outsmart them. Someone else can have the $8 an hour call center job. I will go live in a tent first. Thank you.

  5. James Dustin says:

    Great article, quite informative. I also found another really great website called that will help you get your resume noticed and get you past the ATS plus it only takes a few seconds. Worked for me and I got many more interviews because of jobscan. I definitely recommend the website to anyone who is looking for a job or preparing their resume. Good luck on the job hunt and the resume!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s